From what I hear… failure is an inevitable part of growth. This is the story of my first big crochet fail… and it just happened this week! (Holy cow, a timely post!) It is a story of experimentation, triumph, disappointment, adventure, and quite a few hand cramps.

Luckily, this fail isn’t all doom and gloom. The final product is definitely usable for something… just not its intended purpose.

It all started when my lovely wife asked me for a hat. The kids had been harping on her for not wearing a hat at the bus stop (which is pretty reasonable – it’s been friggin’ 26 degrees out in the morning!)

The particular style of hat she wanted was a popcorn hat. I don’t remember the particular picture she showed me, but it was a cute hat worked in popcorn stitch, with a little brim at the bottom, and I think a flower. She said the flower wasn’t particularly important, so I decided not to make one. I can’t go putting flowers on ALL the hats I make, can I?

I’d been wanting to try working with two strands of yarn at once (for extra bulk and warmth), so I snagged two skeins of a creamy white acrylic/wool blend from our stash (we’ve got a bunch of it!), center-pulled them both perfectly, pulled out a nice new 6.5mm hook (I switched to saw cut! I love it! I should make a separate post about that soon…), and started playing.

Now, for hats, I start at the top and work outward in the round. It just feels natural in my head. I have never done a hat working up from the brim. I should probably try, for the hell of it. It might help in sizing… which I had issues with here.

But for now… we’re going from the top down.

So of course, working top-down in the round, that means I started with a magic circle. I prefer the magic circle to chaining a circle. I find it easier to work into, and the fact that you can cinch it tight before working in your ends tends to result in a cleaner end result. If you’re following along, you could probably ch4 and ss to join instead, if you prefer.

If you haven’t done a magic circle before, it can feel a little weird. I’ve tried a few different methods for the magic circle, but this is the one that feels best in my hand, and it’s wide enough to easily work into, without being so big that it flops around.

This is probably a good time to mention that if you’re wanting to crochet along with this story, I posted the pattern separately. So if my story bores you and you just wanna recreate the hat…

Oh, you’re still here? Then back to the story!

As I said, I worked this hat holding two strands of worsted weight yarn together. I ended up using almost 3 full skeins of yarn. This hat has some heft. And as I discovered later… when working with two strands at once, one skein may run out considerably earlier than the other.

So, anyway. Into the magic circle, I worked 6 popcorn stitches, but it felt wrong. The original idea was to do pure popcorn all the way down to the brim. However, as I toyed with the first row, I ended up doing 7 single crochets into the magic circle, cinching it tight, and working my first round of popcorns into the single crochets. The stitch density felt right with 7.

Before I talk about what I did next, I just want to say. Popcorn stitch is a mess. Mind you, I’m still recovering from 2 months of running our Cub Scout Pack’s big popcorn fundraiser… so the word “popcorn” still triggers a visceral reaction in me. But any stitch that has a step of “remove your hook and reinsert it somewhere else” just seems wrong! WRONG I SAY!

I was also not prepared for how to start each row after the first. Popcorns fit nicely nestled into the stitch space between the popcorns of the previous row… but the starting chain of each row doesn’t line up nicely with that stitch space. I ended up chaining 3 to start each row (counts as the first DC of the popcorn), and working the rest of that first popcorn kinda behind the base of the chain. It makes for an awkward start, but it looks pretty much exactly the same as all the other popcorns… so whatever.

So, let’s see. We’re at row 3… the first “increase”. I wanted a fairly slow, constant slope to the top of the hat, so I went with adding 7 stitches to each row. 7 also happens to be a prime number, which makes it a little awkward to increase evenly at a lower rate. In each space between the 2nd row’s popcorns, I worked two new popcorns. For row 4, I did 2 popcorns in one space, 1 popcorn in the next space, then 2, then 1, etc.

This is about where the first hand cramp came in. I found it really difficult at first to work the second popcorn into each stitch space. It’s tight… I mean, you’re basically working 10 DC stitches around a single chain! So be warned… rest frequently and avoid the temptation to force it. Your hands will thank you.

Now, I was not prepared for just how big double-stranded popcorns were going to be. They’re massive. They’re almost 3/4″ thick, and squishy as all get out. (And they kinda actually look like popcorn… which triggered me again.) But being big… I had some trouble getting the right row count to hit my wife’s head size.

Okay. A lot of trouble.

I thought I got it right, actually, after a few measurements. I stopped increasing, straightening out for 2 rows. And then I tried it on her, thinking I was just going to get a feel for how many rows I was going to need to cover her ears.

Remember when you were a kid, and you put a soup pot or a mixing bowl on top of your head and pretended it was a helmet, or whatever you happened to be pretending?

Yeah. It looked like that… but with pretty white stitches.

So I thought to myself “Oh, it’s only an extra inch-ish of room, I’ll frog a few rows of increases and it’ll be fine.”

LOL

– Me, in hindsight.

So I frogged 4 rows (2 straight, 2 with increases), balling the two strands of yarn together as I frogged it to prevent tangles.

Now, let me tell you something about frogging when you’ve been working with 2 strands. Those strands are not exactly the same length. Because of the way the yarn works in and out of stitches, one strand is going to be longer than the other. What that means for frogging is that they don’t pull out evenly. One of the strands will snag. Constantly. It’s really annoying. 

Or maybe that was just me.

Oh, and did I mention that popcorn uses a TON of yarn? No? Well, popcorn uses a ton of yarn. Now you know.

Okay! All frogged. Let’s start this up again!

With my nice ball of yarn sitting comfortably between me and the two skeins, I went directly into straight rows. I got about halfway through the first row when I realized with growing terror what that ball of yarn was doing.

If you haven’t noticed before… when you do anything with yarn (ball, it crochet it, knit it) it tends to rotate a little. And when you’re pulling from the outside of a ball (or skein), the ball rotates a LOT as you pull yarn off of it. This isn’t usually a problem with one strand of yarn. But with two, wrapped into a ball… that has two strands coming out of its center that are still anchored to their skeins…

I was making a massive twisted tangle between the ball and the two skeins.

Thank goodness for my amazing wife.

My wife is an expert at untangling yarn. She stepped in and helped sort out the mess I’d accidentally created.

She’s the best. That’s why I’m making her a hat!

Okay. Deep breaths. Massive tangle averted. I made it through the next couple rows without incident.

…you know that old adage, “Measure twice, cut once?” Yeah, I really should have been more careful and accurate with my measurements when I realized it was too big. 

It was still friggin big on her.

But that’s okay. I was still super-positive! The popcorns looked pretty, and I’d made it through the tangled mess of frogged yarn without burning the house down or screaming at the children!

So I says “I’ll just do a couple decreases each row to bring it back down, and it’ll be a teensy bit roomy on top but fit snugly on the sides! It’ll be cute and curvy!”

LOLOLOLOL

– Me, also in hindsight.

Now, I wanna tell you something about popcorn decreases.

I don’t know the RIGHT way to do them. And I didn’t look it up. And I STILL haven’t looked it up. And I’m not GONNA look it up. I am stubborn. Like a mule, if a mule had opposable thumbs to hold a crochet hook.

Thus far, my popcorns went like this:

• Work 5 DCs into the stitch space.
• Remove the hook from the loop. (hold the loop so you don’t lose it)
• Insert the hook through the top of the first DC.
• Grab the loop with the hook, pull through, and chain 1 to secure it.

For increases, I’d do that twice in the same stitch space. Tight, but easy. Decreases are a little different, though, because you’re having to pull two stitch spaces together, with the bulk of a popcorn stitch sitting between them.

SO! After a little trial and error… I present… the only-slightly-weird-looking popcorn decrease…

• Work 2 DCs into the first stitch space.
• Work a dc2tog across the popcorn from the previous row. (first half in the first stitch space, second half in the second stitch space)
• Work 2 DCs into the second stitch space.
• Remove the hook from the loop.
• Insert the hook through the top of the first DC.
• Grab the loop with the hook, pull through, and chain 1 to secure it.

For those who aren’t familiar, dc2tog is shorthand for “two double crochets together” – two double crochets with separate bottoms but a single top. It’s also called a “double crochet decrease”. There’s a pretty good video tutorial for it here.

You may be wondering why, if I just looked up a video to show you what a dc2tog is, I haven’t looked up how to do a popcorn decrease. It would be so easy, right?

Stubborn. Like. Mule.

So anyway. It ended up a tiny bit bulkier than the regular popcorns, but it worked! Feeling really good about myself, I moved on. 

A few rows later, I hit the end of one of the skein. I still had probably 1/5 of the other skein left to go. I’d heard that when working with two strands, you often hit the end of one strand before the other. I assume this is largely due to the way the strands wrap around each other and sit differently in your stitches. If you’re working in a single direction, it makes sense that one strand would be consumed a little faster.

I center pulled a fresh skein and tied the ends together, worked it into the middle of a popcorn, and worked the ends in.

About 5 popcorn stitches later, the new skein produced the biggest yarn barf I have ever seen. It had to have been a full quarter of the skein, just BLEARGH! …all over the table. I balled it up (alone this time, not together with the other strand) and moved on without incident.

So I got a few more rows done, the other starting skein died and I tied in its replacement. And then tried it on her head.

-_-

I think you can guess how that went.

Now, there’s no way I was about to frog this thing again. Not after the earlier experience of frogging double-stranded popcorn hell.

So I figured I’d try adding a brim to see how it came out. And hey, maybe the brim would snug it up that last little bit. And if it didn’t… well… I could always go into damage control mode… change the brim and make into a bag or a yarn bowl, or close it off and stuff it to use as a small throw pillow…

I started the brim with single crochet into the stitch spaces and chains across the popcorns, because I really really hate working into popcorns directly. Their tops are usually just too tight, and it distorts their shape to be worked into.

To make it look ribbed, I alternated front post double crochets around each single crochet, and regular double crochets around each chain space. At the front of the hat I did two double crochets in each chain space, to make it wider and naturally turn the brim up and out.

For the next row I did a front post dc around each front post dc, and back post DCs around each regular DC (doubling up in the front again to turn it up more). Then I finished it all off with an edge of single crochets into each stitch.

And done.

I mean… I like it. I like the effect of these massive popcorns in tight little rows. It’s pretty. But… no matter how stubborn I am… it’s just flat out too big for her. And it still ended up way too roomy on top.

Now that I think about it… the extra space in the top might work well for someone with thick, curly hair who needs that extra room on top to not ruin their hairdo… but my wife has straight hair, so it’s just a bubble of airy space up there between her head and the hat. (I’d definitely line it with linen if you’ve got curly hair, though. This thing will frizz you up like you wouldn’t believe.)

Because of how thick the popcorns are, it’s a fairly firm hat. It holds its shape and doesn’t flop much at all. If only it weren’t so big……

Huh. I just noticed that it fits me almost perfectly. Go figure… pity it’s not really my style.

So I guess it’s not a total failure after all…